Skip to main content

Shelter Island Heights Yachts for Sale

Which Yacht?

Price  •  Length  •  Location
Make or Model

Price

Length

Location

Town of Shelter Island, New York, US


More Filters

3D Tour


Video


Spotlight

Sag Harbor, New York

KMB Yachting, LLC.
2025 Cantieri Capelli Stradivari 43

Sag Harbor, New York

KMB Yachting, LLC.

2021 Pursuit S 328

$350,000
from $2,079/Mo
2021 Pursuit S 328

Rye, New York

Allied Marine
1984 Beneteau First 42

Northport, New York

Engel & Volkers Yachting

2024 Pardo Yachts P43

$999,000
from $5,934/Mo

Huntington, New York

Allied Marine

2025 Technohull GTX

$398,000
from $2,364/Mo
2025 Technohull GTX

Sag Harbor, New York

KMB Yachting, LLC.

2021 Wally Wallytender43X

$998,000
from $5,928/Mo

Quogue, New York

Allied Marine

2008 Sea Ray Sundancer 60

$649,000
from $3,855/Mo

Huntington, New York

Allied Marine
2014 Herreshoff Yacht Buzzard Bay 15

Huntington, New York

Rick Obey Yacht Sales

New Rochelle, New York

26 North Yachts

2025 Technohull GTX

$399,000
from $2,370/Mo

Sag Harbor, New York

KMB Yachting, LLC.

2016 Riva Rivarama Super

$595,000
from $3,534/Mo
2016 Riva Rivarama Super

East Hampton, New York

Tait Yachts

2024 Tiara Yachts 48LE

$1,799,000
$100K
from $10,685/Mo

Montauk, New York

Italian Yacht Group

2014 Hinckley Yachts Talaria 48 Flybridge

$1,749,000
$46K
from $10,388/Mo

Montauk, New York

Italian Yacht Group
2020 Formula Boats 400 Super Sport Crossover

East Northport, New York

26 North Yachts

2019 Tiara Yachts 34LX

$345,000
from $2,049/Mo
2019 Tiara Yachts 34LX

Sag Harbor, New York

Tait Yachts

2010 Sea Ray 500 Sundancer

$465,000
$5K
from $2,762/Mo

Huntington, New York

OneWater Yacht Group

2025 Black Pepper Code 0.1

Contact for Pricing

Sag Harbor, New York

Tait Yachts

2025 Black Pepper Code #

Contact for Pricing

Sag Harbor, New York

Tait Yachts

2024 Black Pepper Code 0.1

Contact for Pricing
2024 Black Pepper Code 0.1

Sag Harbor, New York

Tait Yachts
layout sider

Shelter Island Heights Yachts for Sale

Shelter Island Heights yachts for sale appeal to buyers looking for vessels located in one of the most charming and strategically positioned boating communities in the Northeast. Set between the North and South Forks of Long Island, Shelter Island Heights offers protected waters, classic yachting heritage, and immediate access to both Peconic Bay and open ocean routes.

For buyers seeking a refined boating environment with strong cruising flexibility and long term appeal, yachts located in Shelter Island Heights represent a highly desirable opportunity.

Why Buy a Yacht Located in Shelter Island Heights

Yachts based in Shelter Island Heights are often owned by seasoned boaters who value tradition, careful upkeep, and thoughtful ownership. Many vessels in this market show strong maintenance histories, conservative usage patterns, and upgrades aligned with Northeast cruising conditions.

The location itself is a major advantage. Shelter Island Heights provides protected harbor access while allowing quick runs to Sag Harbor, Greenport, Montauk, and the broader Long Island Sound. Buyers benefit from a quieter marina setting without sacrificing proximity to some of the region’s most iconic boating destinations.

Types of Yachts Commonly Found in Shelter Island Heights

The local inventory reflects the area’s blend of classic yachting culture and modern cruising. Yachts here are often selected for elegance, seaworthiness, and comfortable onboard living.

Common yacht types include:

  • Motor yachts from 35 to 85 feet
  • Downeast and classic style cruisers
  • Flybridge yachts for family cruising
  • Express cruisers and sport yachts
  • Sailboats and motorsailers with cruising focus

Many vessels are equipped for seasonal use with strong emphasis on comfort and reliability.

Typical Pricing for Shelter Island Heights Yachts

Pricing in Shelter Island Heights generally reflects the desirability of the location and the quality of vessels available. Buyers are often paying for careful ownership and prime positioning as much as the yacht itself.

Typical price ranges include:

  • 250,000 to 600,000 USD for smaller cruisers
  • 600,000 to 1.8 million USD for mid size motor yachts
  • 1.8 million USD and above for larger or newer yachts

Inventory often peaks in late spring and early summer as owners prepare for the season.

How Owners Use Yachts in Shelter Island Heights

Yachts located in Shelter Island Heights are commonly used for elegant coastal cruising and seasonal enjoyment rather than high volume use. Owners often focus on quality time aboard and destination driven boating.

Common uses include:

  • Cruising the Peconic Bay and Long Island Sound
  • Visiting Sag Harbor, Greenport, and Montauk
  • Weekend and summer liveaboard use
  • Entertaining guests in protected harbors
  • Coastal passages toward New England

The area supports a relaxed yet sophisticated boating lifestyle.

What Buyers Should Inspect When Buying in Shelter Island Heights

Northeast boating conditions require careful inspection, particularly for yachts exposed to seasonal weather cycles and winter storage. Buyers should pay close attention to systems related to comfort and structural integrity.

Key inspection areas include:

  • Engines, cooling systems, and exhaust components
  • Heating systems and insulation
  • Hull condition and moisture intrusion
  • Electrical systems and shore power compatibility
  • Canvas, enclosures, and brightwork condition

A professional marine survey and engine inspection are essential before closing.

Advantages of Buying a Yacht Already Located in Shelter Island Heights

Purchasing a yacht already based in Shelter Island Heights reduces transport costs and simplifies sea trials in familiar waters. Many yachts are already positioned in historic marinas with experienced local service providers who understand the demands of Northeast cruising.

Buyers also benefit from immediate access to some of Long Island’s most desirable boating routes.

Who Shelter Island Heights Yachts Are Best For

Shelter Island Heights yachts are ideal for buyers who value location, heritage, and refined cruising over high traffic marina environments. The market attracts both experienced yachtsmen and buyers seeking a classic Northeast boating base.

These yachts are well suited for:

  • Buyers planning Long Island Sound and Peconic Bay cruising
  • Owners seeking a quiet yet connected marina location
  • Families prioritizing seasonal cruising and entertaining
  • Buyers focused on long term ownership appeal

Explore Shelter Island Heights Yachts for Sale

Shelter Island Heights yachts for sale offer a rare combination of charm, access, and enduring value. With protected waters, iconic destinations nearby, and a deeply rooted yachting culture, this market continues to attract buyers looking for thoughtful, location driven yacht ownership.

Explore Shelter Island Heights yachts for sale on YachtWay to compare listings, review pricing, and find the right vessel for your cruising plans. Your Yacht. Your Way. YachtWay.